4-3 overall
2002: 1-2
Got swept by Tampa and Atlanta. Beat NO in the season finale.
2003: 2-0
Beat Dallas and Philly in the playoffs after losing to both during the season.
2004: 0-1
Lost twice to Atlanta.
2005: 1-0
Beat NO on the second try.
So recent history (2003 on) favors the Panthers. The one loss in that span was the OT game with Vick's 4th and 12 miracle play, I believe.