The Top 5 QBs

[rake]

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=4884358

a reason to pull for the saints this weekend . .. Brees' new deal should equal Peytons in vastness . . . projected 4 years 72 million with 36 to 40 guaranteed


click on the Cowherd podcast clip below that video if you have 4 minutes.

2 Mannings, one Brees, a Brady, who is the fifth? He mentions Warner and Favre but Warner is gone and even if Favre lingers one more year I doubt he gets top 5 QB dollars.

 

[gridfaniker]

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=4884358

a reason to pull for the saints this weekend . .. Brees' new deal should equal Peytons in vastness . . . projected 4 years 72 million with 36 to 40 guaranteed


click on the Cowherd podcast clip below that video if you have 4 minutes.

2 Mannings, one Brees, a Brady, who is the fifth? He mentions Warner and Favre but Warner is gone and even if Favre lingers one more year I doubt he gets top 5 QB dollars.

rivers

 

[Thelt]

My Top Ten:

1. Peyton
2. Brady
3. Brees
4. Rivers
5. Roethlisberger
6. Rogers
7. Favre
8. Schaub
9. Eli
10. McRib

 

[presidence99]

9. Eli

Seriously?

 

[Pi.]

Seriously?

I know. He was one hail mary away from being the goat of that superbowl. What else has he done?

 

[rake]

Cowherds thing was the top 5 based on their value to the teams they lead . ..

I remember when jake had that top 5 (or at least top 10) sort of value to the panthers . ..

 

[Dbag21]

if Peyton is Archies son,I think Eli might be the mailmans boy

 

[chipshot]

Cowherds thing was the top 5 based on their value to the teams they lead . ..

Ok, how is that different than top 5 qbs?

Eli is not top 5 no matter how you look at it.

 

[Thelt]

Eli had a good year. He is not the reason the Giants sucked. He proved he can get it done with out Plaxico this year.

 

[rake]

Ok, how is that different than top 5 qbs?

Usually it's based purely on stats

this was from the POV of who is the most irreplaceable to their team . ..

click that arrow on the audio thingy and give a listen