my top 128 (somebody had to do it)

[Wp28]

go ahead - kill it!

1 1 QB Matt Leinart
2 2 RB Reggie Bush
3 3 QB Vince Young
4 4 T D'Brickashaw Ferguson
5 5 DT Haloti Ngata
6 6 LB AJ Hawk
7 7 DB Jimmy Williams
8 8 DE Mario Williams
9 9 LB Chad Greenway
10 10 RB LenDale White
11 11 RB DeAngelo Williams
12 12 DE Tamba Hali
13 13 TE Vernon Davis
14 14 DE Manny Lawson
15 15 T Marcus McNeill
16 16 DB Michael Huff
17 17 DB Ko Simpson
18 18 QB Jay Cutler
19 19 WR Santonio Holmes
20 20 TE Marcedes Lewis
21 21 DT Brodrick Bunkley
22 22 DE Mathias Kiwanuka
23 23 DB Antonio Cromartie
24 24 DT Gabe Watson
25 25 DB Tye Hill
26 26 DB Ashton Youboty
27 27 TE Leonard Pope
28 28 T Winston Justice
29 29 G Max Jean-Gilles
30 30 DT Rodrique Wright
31 31 WR Sinorice Moss
32 32 RB Laurence Maroney
(Round 2)
1 33 T Eric Winston
2 34 WR Chad Jackson
3 35 LB DeMeco Ryans
4 36 WR Derek Hagan
5 37 C Nick Mangold
6 38 LB Bobby Carpenter
7 39 G Charles Spencer
8 40 T Daryn Colledge
9 41 DB Darnell Bing
10 42 DT Orien Harris
11 43 DT Babatunde Oshinowo
12 44 G Taitusi Lutui
13 45 DB Cedric Griffin
14 46 RB Joseph Addai
15 47 RB Brian Calhoun
16 48 WR Martin Nance
17 49 DE Darryl Tapp
18 50 G Davin Joseph
19 51 TE Anthony Fasano
20 52 DE Kamerion Wimbley
21 53 T Jonathan Scott
22 54 RB Jerome Harrison
23 55 DT Jesse Mahelona
24 56 WR Demetrius Williams
25 57 DB Alan Zemaitis
26 58 LB Abdul Hodge
27 59 DB Greg Blue
28 60 DT Kyle Williams
29 61 DE Elvis Dumervil
30 62 WR Maurice Stovall
31 63 WR Michael Robinson
32 64 DB Pat Watkins
(round 3)
1 65 WR Devin Hester
2 66 C Greg Eslinger
3 67 TE Dominique Byrd
4 68 DB Charles Gordon
5 69 DB Kelly Jennings
6 70 DB Anwar Phillips
7 71 LB Kai Parham
8 72 DB Richard Marshall
9 73 LB D’Qwell Jackson
10 74 DB Demetrice Webb
11 75 DB Roman Harper
12 76 G Fred Matua
13 77 LB Spencer Havner
14 78 T Ryan O' Callaghan
15 79 DB Jason Allen
16 80 DE Parys Haralson
17 81 QB Charlie Whitehurst
18 82 LB Fred Roach
19 83 DT Claude Wroten
20 84 RB Cedric Humes
21 85 DB DeMario Minter
22 86 WR Greg Lee
23 87 WR Jason Avant
24 88 TE Tim Day
25 89 LB Gerris Wilkinson
26 90 C Mike Degory
27 91 WR Mike Hass
28 92 DB Will Blackmon
29 93 G Will Allen
30 94 DB Tim Jennings
31 95 WR Hank Baskett
32 96 WR Travis Wilson
(round 4)
1 97 DB Johnathan Joseph
2 98 DT Dusty Dvoracek
3 99 RB Jerious Norwood
4 100 DB Darrell Hunter
5 101 LB Brandon Johnson
6 102 RB Andre Hall
7 103 TE Joe Klopfenstein
8 104 TE David Thomas
9 105 DB Daniel Bullocks
10 106 LB Tim Dobbins
11 107 QB Omar Jacobs
12 108 QB Bruce Gradkowski
13 109 TE Jeff King
14 110 DB Aaron Gipson
15 111 LB Ernie Sims
16 112 DE Ray Edwards
17 113 DE Stanley McClover
18 114 DE Eric Henderson
19 115 DB Gabe Fulbright
20 116 C Will Montgomery
21 117 RB Mike Bell
22 118 FB Matt Bernstein
23 119 RB DonTrell Moore
24 120 DB Nate Salley
25 121 RB Maurice Drew
26 122 TE T.J. Williams
27 123 WR Jonathan Orr
28 124 C Ryan Cook
29 125 DB Donte Whitner
30 126 DE Victor Adeyanju
31 127 DB Jarrad Page
32 128 LB Thomas Howard

 

[hasbeen99]

Um, by "kill it", do you mean critique it or mock it?

 

[Wp28]

Um, by "kill it", do you mean critique it or mock it?

only if you feel the need.

 

[Purrsecutioner]

I just dont see us taking a TE in the first round.

 

[Wp28]

I just dont see us taking a TE in the first round.

it's not a mock, just a rated list of prospects

 

[gridfaniker]

AJ Hawk

 

[lde]

From what I've read, Greenway is too high. I won't quibble with White over Williams at RB, since they're different and its a matter of what you like. R. Wright is probably too high. Is Hawk on there? He should probably be top 5. McNeil will vary with opinions. I bet he's too high.

I just scanned it real quick but otherwise it looks reasonable.

 

[Wp28]

From what I've read, Greenway is too high. Is Hawk on there? He should probably be top 5. McNeil will vary with opinions. I bet he's too high.

I just scanned it real quick but otherwise it looks reasonable.

Doh! fixed.

 

[Collin]

I liked it better when I thought it was a mock. As a straight-up ranking I disagree with quite a lot of it.

 

[Wp28]

I liked it better when I thought it was a mock. As a straight-up ranking I disagree with quite a lot of it.

well, if you want to look at it as a mock , we went

27 27 TE Leonard Pope
27 59 DB Greg Blue
26 90 C Mike Degory
27 123 WR Jonathan Orr

Orr any good?