is this not crap??

I say Fields and McGahee should be #1 and #2 and I would not argue the order either way. Fields of course battled cancer and anyone that saw McGahee's last college game still sees that leg bending in directions it is not supposed to bend. I thought he was done for good. Vick I will give some right to be on the list because he also had an injury to return from

Dillon? He moved to the SB champs...What is the amazing factor there?

Griese and Brees are insults on this list. One year of not sucking is all they accomplished
 
solarte1969 said:
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=1960406

fields 2ND IN COMEBACK PLAYER OF THE YEAR VOTE!!!


BREES ONBLY BEAT HIS LACK OF ABILITY--FIELDS BEAT FRIGGIN CANCER!

Without practicing (and not sucking), which really makes you tired Brees would surely lose his starting job and may only make a million or two as a back-up.

Without chemo, which really makes you sick, tired and burns your insides up, Fields would surely lose his starting job, his career, and possibly his life.

Both had successful seasons. I can see where it would be close. :teeth:
 
Fields & McGahee are by far the most deserving IMO.

Even Vicks injury wasnt life or career threatening.
 
Fields and co. "came back" from something. Brees should have won the "most improved" award like the NBA has
 

Members online

Latest posts

Trending content

Forum statistics

Threads
158,340
Posts
2,824,038
Members
11,199
Latest member
garyfrank231
Back
Top