M
mramailman
Guest
This is targeted at magnus and anyone who is a fan of this band
Let me start by saying I think they lost alot on June 30th of 99 with Tom Maxwell resigning from SNZ. He brought a bit of balance to the "power" over the band that Jimbo Mathus and Katherine Whalen held. Also he helped in the zippering of the music..... if you're a fan you'll know what I mean.
mVm, how do you feel about Je Widenhouse compared to the late Stacy Guess?
I feel that Guess brought more to the band with his playing style and ability and musical writing. It seems to me, a non-musician, that Guess could hit higher notes, whether live or not, and had better rythm with the band. He played with not much credit on Hot and their earlier work. Je, a talented musician, can play the horn rather well just not as good as Stacy. If you listen to Hot and then listen Perennial Favorites you can hear a drastic change in the effectivness and range of the horn IMO.
Listen to Bedalm Ballroom off of the Sold Out release to hear some of Stacy's best work. I haven't heard Je play that well or write that good of a song. It seems that Mathus and Whalen write most of their music now and hell(like the pun) I don't know if they even zipper the music now. Also get La Grippe off that same release is played with Bio Ritmo the salsa band I mentioned in an e-mail a few weeks ago.
Hot is IMHO their best album followed by Perennial Favorites, Sold Out, The Inevitable and finally Bedlam Ballroom. I've heard and seen great reviews of Ballroom but it lacked some of Maxwell's qualities. I have all of them except for Bedlam Ballroom, which I have downloaded, and I like it but I don't love as much as the earlier stuff.
I could type alot more but I think that's enough
I was hoping to get a musicians take on this....... anyone musically inclined or a fan of the band please reply.... thanks
Let me start by saying I think they lost alot on June 30th of 99 with Tom Maxwell resigning from SNZ. He brought a bit of balance to the "power" over the band that Jimbo Mathus and Katherine Whalen held. Also he helped in the zippering of the music..... if you're a fan you'll know what I mean.
mVm, how do you feel about Je Widenhouse compared to the late Stacy Guess?
I feel that Guess brought more to the band with his playing style and ability and musical writing. It seems to me, a non-musician, that Guess could hit higher notes, whether live or not, and had better rythm with the band. He played with not much credit on Hot and their earlier work. Je, a talented musician, can play the horn rather well just not as good as Stacy. If you listen to Hot and then listen Perennial Favorites you can hear a drastic change in the effectivness and range of the horn IMO.
Listen to Bedalm Ballroom off of the Sold Out release to hear some of Stacy's best work. I haven't heard Je play that well or write that good of a song. It seems that Mathus and Whalen write most of their music now and hell(like the pun) I don't know if they even zipper the music now. Also get La Grippe off that same release is played with Bio Ritmo the salsa band I mentioned in an e-mail a few weeks ago.
Hot is IMHO their best album followed by Perennial Favorites, Sold Out, The Inevitable and finally Bedlam Ballroom. I've heard and seen great reviews of Ballroom but it lacked some of Maxwell's qualities. I have all of them except for Bedlam Ballroom, which I have downloaded, and I like it but I don't love as much as the earlier stuff.
I could type alot more but I think that's enough
I was hoping to get a musicians take on this....... anyone musically inclined or a fan of the band please reply.... thanks