Realistic options for 2010 qb?

what he has now is ridiculous, sure. There have also been some good coaches go through there.
I'm saying either the guy is a good enough QB or he's not, there's not a lot of need for exceptions.

 

Thelt took the other side of it - that Washington supposedly has no offensive talent.

 

brian st pierre
or
matt guiterrez
then we pay for wr
kevin walters

 

this may or am not be taken out of context.

 

Take all the QBs we have now out back put a bullet in their head. Then let mangus go pick.

 

We can't forget there is likely to be a mass exodus from college this year with the injuries to Tebow and Bradford. May want to do some serious homework on these guys and find that sleeper.

 

Tim Tebow doesnt break wind…….thats the air crapping all over itself trying to get out of Tebow’s way..
Killing Tim Tebow doesn’t make him dead. It just makes him angry.
Tim Tebow doesn’t do pushups, he pushes the earth down.
Tim Tebow’s tears cure cancer, to bad he’s never cried.
If Tim Tebow was in a room with Hitler, Stalin, and Nina Meyers, and he had a gun with 2 bullets, he’d shoot Nina twice.
If you wake up in the morning, it’s because Tim Tebow spared your life.
Superman wears Tim Tebow pajamas.

 

I am not sure I communicated clearly what I thought about the OC in relation to the QB or other players on offense. I do think a bad OC can limit a QB. If the OC has a bad game plan, a poorly designed offense or does a bad job of play calling then he can make a QB look bad. I do not think that the OC or any coach on the pro level will often take a player and mold him from a sap into a quality NFL starter. If a guy does not know how to play the game by the time he gets to the NFL the OC is not going to be able to teach him.

It is not like Apollo Creed training Rocky to be a better fighter. The best OC in the game was not going to make Joey Harrington or David Carr into pro bowl players.

 

How can you not read that as coaching doesn't matter?

 

Did you read the first part of what I said? Coaching matter when it comes to a team winning or losing but I do not think it matters much when it comes to how good an individual player is going to be.

I am curious how much blame do you put on coaches for the big time busts that we have seen over the years? Do you think guys like Ryan Leaf, Akili Smith, Joey Harrington, etc would have been star players if they had been under the right OC?