More important: Cam or Chud?

Ok, fair enough. I deserve that then. There is enough difference between "could" and "would", and I accept that.

But really, Chud could look pretty fucking bad with a different QB too, as he did in his second year in Cleveland.

He's done a wonderful job with Cam, as has Shula. But to suggest, or even infer that Cam is a star just because of Chud is disingenuous.

We can't discount what Shula has done, and how hard Cam has worked.

 

Collin

Have you changed your opinion on Cam's ability to be a successful qb in this league or not? I would love to hear your thoughts after what we have seen so far this season. Also, early in the year you were extremely critical of our redzone offense, what are your thoughts now?

 

Um...I was always a Cam mark, dude. In the beginning I was critical of the red zone offense because it was deserving. I was also critical of some of Cam's mechanics because he needed work on them.

He has come along greatly. I credit Chud, Shula, and Cam's ridiculous work ethic. But changed my mind on his ability to be a successful QB?

Get your posters right, bro. I've been a Cam mark for a long time. I had my concerns like anyone else, but normally I'm being accused of being too much a fanboy of him.

Yes, I think he can be a successful QB in this league.

And yes, our redzone offense has come a long way. I credit Chud for that. He's got a diverse set of run plays, he's running our backs more in there, and using playaction a ton more. He's adjusted, utilizing our strengths, and being creative. It's working.

Is that ok with you? Your question came off as a bit confrontational, so if it wasn't intended as so, my apologies.



EDIT- Ah, now I see you've edited it for Collin.

Disregard then.

 

No, my opinion hasn't changed significantly. I always said he was the best QB prospect in the draft, and that he had plenty of passing ability. It will be some time before we know how he develops in terms of reading defenses, anticipating receivers getting open, footwork, and accuracy. He's damn fun to watch and makes Panthers games entertaining, though.

 

You put that in quotes but that's not what Collin said.

 

+1

 

I hope it's a long time before it ever matters one versus the other. They work together really well, and to a point let's credit Shula, since Chud is an OC without QB coach experience.

There are some head scratchers of course, but Chud is calling a fantastic season. Needs more run, and to a point the RBs haven't been as big a factor in the passing game as you might imagine (but that's partly a QB who doesn't check down as much).

There are some things that Cam can do in this offense he couldn't in others, and there's obviously some stuff this O couldn't do without him. I did have worries that he couldn't do what the O needed, so maybe that leans toward Chud, but it's a team game for a reason. Both have exceeded my expectations at what they're good at.

 

Cam

 

Ok, so I answered your question. Can you take Collin's dick out of your mouth to answer mine, or are you just going to agree with him so he's your friend.

My guess is the latter.

 

I'd bet Cam wouldn't be at this point with last year's coaching staff!!