If I was Andrew Luck

Peyton Manning

 

Why?

I keep hearing that sentiment, but what's the alternative. Stay in school only to go drafted by ANOTHER shitty 1-whatever team? By being the best, you go to the worst, and that's the way it's always been. If he's guaranteed to go 1, he needs to fucking move. God forbid, someone else leapfrogs him next year, and he lose millions upon millions.

Really. We have a good core. Salty defense, young and emerging receivers, great RBs, ok line. The worst part of our team is the QB position. Why wouldn't he want to come in and be a part of that solution?

 

was thinking him but couldn't remember if they had him as the clear #1

 

Lienart had a good shot at it too if I remember right and he stayed in school another year.

I think Eli was projected to go very high if not number one overall after his junior year but he stayed.

Ralph Sampson stayed in school when he could have gone number one in the NBA.

 

I think there was some debate between Peyton and Ryan Leaf. Manning had a reputation of losing the big ones

 

Tim Duncan stayed at Wake Forest 4 yrs. He could have been the #1 after his soph year, and he was still the #1 pick as a sr.

 

Also depends on who the next coach is.

 

Tim Duncan, twice.

EDIT: Should have read the whole thread