Struggling Panthers QB Carr demoted to 3rd string

Carr has only started four games although! He came in to two other games, Atlanta and Indy and was sacked of course in each of those games. The only two games he started and didn't have multiple sacks was against the Saints, one of the worst defenses in the league (only 3 more sacks then the Panthers!)

Atlanta: relieved Jake, 1 sack
Tampa: 3 sacks
Saints: 1 sack, this was the Saints first sack of the year.
Indy: relieved Vinny, 1 sack
Tenn: oh boy 7 sacks
Saints: 1 sack, again team is in the bottom of league in sacks.

 

Collin is PARTLY right. Carr sucks and the offense sucks.

 

Dude, even when Carr doesn't get sacked, he makes the O-line look like shit...that should be obvious to even the dullest Panther fan by now. I can assure you that the coaching staff has noticed it.

For the record, I don't hate the guy at all. In fact, I have actually defended him from some of the more vulgar comments that some posters have made about him. I just don't like him as the Panthers QB...I wish him well in everything else he does.

 

The offense looked pretty good when Jake was in there. It has looked below average with Vinny and horrible with Carr. I think it is safe to say that Carr sucks.

 

You keep saying things are "obvious" only to get your ass kicked every time you try to argue something. Perhaps you ought to reevaluate what you consider "obvious," and only apply that adjective to things you can actually prove.

You've even blamed him for the times when we didn't run the ball well. You've blamed him for everything and made an ass out of yourself by making outlandish claims about him when there were plenty of opportunities for legitimate criticism. It is beyond clear that you do hate the guy, and that you're rabidly biased against him.

 

Game.
Set.
Match.

 

I think "obvious" is very applicable in Carr's case...to everybody but you , anyway. You want me to prove everything with words, when all I need are my own eyes and common sense, while at the same time, you state that I hate the guy as if it's a proven fact, when there is no way in hell you can "prove" what's in my heart. Hypocrite...

 

Dude, you made all sorts of bullshit claims that I proved wrong or otherwise exposed as invalid every single time. You only need common sense to know that Carr a) wasn't playing well, b) was limiting the offense, and c) is too shell shocked to be playing up to his talent right now.

Again, that stuff is why I said from the first moment we signed him that I hoped he wouldn't play a down for us in '07 so that he could work out his issues and be rebuilt as the quarterback he can be. Instead it's basically like we took a hobbled horse and ran him at the tracks with a fat jockey on his back (defense, special teams, play-calling, etc). No one should be surprised that he couldn't carry the team that way, but he didn't suddenly become talentless either.